In the socratic seminar today people stated there different oppinions on the book Montana 1948. Many people say that it is one of the better books we read this year. Others said that it is boring and slow. David was tring to get his parents tell him what happend with Marie even though he really knew what he was talking about. He did this to try to see if his parents would open up to him. The controversy about if Wes does the right thing remaining loyal to his brother. I feel that no mater how badly your brother messes up, you should cover for them because they are family. Family is the most important thing in life and once you lose a member of that family, the chain brakes. Another topic that was brought up was, is david a good narrator and why was he chosen. He is the narrator because he didnt choose a side yet and he is learning about the situation at the time.